Josh Hokit's behavior has undergone a dramatic shift since his MMA debut at Bellator 300 in October 2023, when he was described as gracious and normal, thanking coaches, parents, and fans. As recently as six months ago, Hokit maintained his authentic personality, but this year he has adopted an over-the-top persona characterized by antics at weigh-ins and constant theatrics. While this approach generates content for social media platforms, critics argue that constantly playing a character becomes tiresome and difficult to watch. A recent interview with Ariel Helwani showcased Hokit acting wild from start to finish, which observers found unbearable. The commentary suggests fighters should know when to dial back their personas rather than maintaining them constantly.

