A discussion is proposed about the ideal next opponent for Islam Makhachev, with the author suggesting Ian Garry first, followed by Carlos Prates. The reasoning is that both matchups would generate significant buzz and conflict outside the cage while being competitive and dangerous for Makhachev inside it. The post suggests fans are looking for rivalry and excitement beyond just the fight itself. The author notes that Shavkat Rakhmonov doesn't generate the same level of hype, and invites readers to share their preferred opponent sequence in the comments.
A debate is circulating among MMA fans about who Islam Makhachev should fight next in the welterweight division, with one prominent discussion proposing a specific two-fight sequence: Ian Garry first, then Carlos Prates. The conversation argues that both matchups carry enough conflict and intrigue outside the cage to match their competitiveness inside it.
Makhachev, 34, enters this discussion as the reigning welterweight champion and the top-ranked pound-for-pound fighter in the sport. The Russian, who trains with Eagles MMA, holds a 28-1 record and has built his dominance on elite grappling, averaging 3.2 takedowns per 15 minutes with 58 percent striking accuracy. He is a difficult puzzle for any opponent to solve.
Carlos Prates, nicknamed "The Nightmare," sits fifth in the welterweight rankings with a 24-7 record. The 32-year-old Brazilian out of Vale Top Team is a switch-stance striker who lands 3.77 significant strikes per minute — one of the higher output rates in the division — and carries a 78-inch reach that gives him serious range advantages at six-foot-one. The discussion frames him as a genuinely dangerous test for the champion.
Shavkat Rakhmonov, ranked third at welterweight, is acknowledged in the conversation but set aside on the grounds that he does not generate the same level of public excitement. The Kazakh known as "Nomad" is undefeated at 19-0 and arguably the most statistically complete welterweight outside the champion, connecting on 60 percent of his significant strikes while averaging 1.4 takedowns and 1.2 submission attempts per 15 minutes.
Why it matters
- Makhachev moving to welterweight has reshuffled the division's title picture entirely
- Prates offers a high-volume striking threat that contrasts sharply with Makhachev's grappling identity
- Rakhmonov's place in the queue remains a genuine question despite his undefeated record and top-three ranking
- The sequencing of title challengers will shape the welterweight landscape through the next year
