A discussion has emerged regarding who should be Islam Makhachev's next opponent, with Ian Garry and Carlos Prates being the primary candidates considered. The preference expressed is for Garry first, followed by Prates, based on the buildup and conflict potential outside the cage. Both matchups are viewed as competitive and dangerous for Makhachev while generating significant fan interest. Shavkat Rakhmonov is mentioned as generating less promotional buzz. The post seeks community input on the optimal sequencing of potential title defenses.
A debate has surfaced among MMA fans over who Islam Makhachev should face next in his first welterweight title defense, with Ian Garry and Carlos Prates emerging as the two names generating the most discussion.
Makhachev, 34, carries a 28-1 record and holds the welterweight championship while also sitting atop the pound-for-pound rankings. The Russian southpaw from Eagles MMA is a relentless grappler, averaging 3.2 takedowns per 15 minutes with 58 percent striking accuracy. His path to dominance at 170 pounds has been marked by smothering control and a high submission threat.
Prates, nicknamed "The Nightmare," enters the conversation ranked fifth at welterweight with a 24-7 record. The 32-year-old Brazilian out of Vale Top Team is a switch-stance striker who lands 3.77 significant strikes per minute, the highest output among the candidates being discussed. Standing six-foot-one with a 78-inch reach — the longest of any fighter in this debate — he presents a legitimate volume-striking problem for anyone in the division.
Shavkat Rakhmonov, ranked third at welterweight, also draws mention but is viewed in the discussion as generating less promotional momentum despite holding a perfect 19-0 record. The 31-year-old Kazakh known as "Nomad" is a well-rounded threat, posting 60 percent striking accuracy alongside 1.4 takedowns and 1.2 submission attempts per 15 minutes.
Why it matters
- Makhachev's first welterweight title defense carries enormous divisional stakes, with multiple ranked contenders in position to challenge
- Garry and Prates are seen as stronger box-office options due to outside-the-cage conflict potential
- Prates brings elite striking volume and a lengthy frame that could test Makhachev's takedown-heavy approach
- Rakhmonov's flawless record keeps him firmly in the conversation despite quieter promotional appeal
